Community Forum : Discussion Forum
Welcome Guest   
 
 Subject : Re:Classifying Peer Mentorship Experiences.. 09/28/2025 10:48:21 AM 
Marianna Savoca
Posts: 4
Location
HI Paige,
While we do not have an institutional definition of peer mentoring, there are several long-running successful programs in lots of places. Some are credit bearing leadership experiences, some are paid positions, and some are both.

We encourage the use of the SEE Principles of Effective Practice and a sound assessment of learning as with any ExL activity.

I like the idea of tagging these experiences specifically as peer mentoring. We are exploring this idea right now!

Best wishes,
Marianna
 Subject : Re:Re:Classifying Peer Mentorship Experiences.. 09/26/2025 01:37:59 PM 
Paige Andersson
Posts: 2
Location
Thanks Bill, this is helpful perspective! We also talked about creating a tag just for peer mentoring, but we weren't sure if that over complicated things. Good to know others have felt that was necessary.
 Subject : Re:Classifying Peer Mentorship Experiences.. 09/25/2025 12:21:49 PM 
Bill Heinrich
Posts: 5
Location: Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Hi Paige,

When we did a project focused on co-curricular records when I was at Michigan State, we evaluated the design of the EL against criteria (you mentioned "having a mentor and structured reflection") separately from the title of the role. Because programs often use different language for similar ideas, we essentially conducted tiny program evaluations each entry in the catalog to determine how to include. For intensity (especially w/co-curricular) we used a combination of hours/time on task and a more subjective evaluation of stated learning outcomes or project deliverables.

https://ser.msu.edu/

Over time we saw that peer mentoring fell into leadership categories like peer support for various clubs and programs; employment like peer crisis/help lines or peer-academic tutoring; and credit bearing (fewer) but peer mentor or TA--so peer mentoring became a tag or secondary category. We could still search for and report on it that way.

Here's a decent peer mentor primer if it helps: https://doi.org/10.1108/978-1-78635-064-020161011

Bill Heinrich
 Subject : Classifying Peer Mentorship Experiences.. 09/25/2025 10:19:52 AM 
Paige Andersson
Posts: 2
Location
Hi all,

I'd love your input on how (or if) your institutions view peer mentorship as experiential learning. At IU Bloomington, we have a number of campus programs submitting applications for our Co-Curricular (not for credit) Experiential Learning Designation that fall into the realm of Peer Mentorship. The committee is debating whether to classify these as student employment, student leadership, or internships.

There is a range in duties. For example, in many cases, the peer mentors assist or generate programming and offer some direct student support (e.g. in career services offices). In others, peer mentors support students in undergraduate research programs or first year seminar courses.

I think we're leaning toward student employment, but this creates a challenge for those experiences that require mentors to enroll in credit (or that are unpaid, which we would discourage, and are for credit only).

Some also have misgivings that these experiences may not offer the same degree of networking or work integrated practices as an internship. All our EL activities must be mentored with structured reflection to receive the designation. We also classify activities by intensity, so any thoughts you have on distinguishing low-higher impact/intensity peer mentorship for the peer mentor would be welcome, too!

Thanks in advance for your insights,

Paige Andersson (IUB)
 
# of Topics per Page